Cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

How much activity daily?

ANSWERED

After having been sedentary and then recuperating, I am finally ready to get moving and take off this extra weight.  I have been walking regularly, just started strength training so it's light,  and eating well - healthy food and just around my calorie allowance (1200 -1300 most days). I have not lost one pound yet.  I am mid 60s, sedentary for years.  I thought the changes alone would have turned things around, but nothing.

I am curious - how much exercise do you  get?  I looked up numbers of calories for various amounts of walking - there is no way that will get me to burn 500 calories daily, and I was hoping for more than 1 pound weekly. 

Am I grossly underestimating what is needed?

Thanks.

The activity that seems impossible today, will soon be your warm-up
Best Answer
1 BEST ANSWER

Accepted Solutions

Hey @Bobbinyc

 

First things first, consult a doctor.  They may or may not recommend something other than this.  I am not a doctor, I just keep at what shows results and what I enjoy.  Because I think bottom line, if you don't at least somewhat enjoy it.. you won't keep at it.

 

Here's the thing... I have never seen a fool proof workout/diet plan for everyone.  There is no magic formula as in (eat this) + (do this) = (drop weight like magic).  Every one has their own thing.  There are a million diets, a million different ways to get active.  I don't necessarily think they are all 100% right.. or wrong for that matter.  If it works for you.. It works!

 

I personally think your activity level has everything to do with you.  Do what you can tolerate.  By that I mean general soreness is going to be something to get used to at least for a while.  As long as it is tolerable to you, keep it up.  Find an activity that you like to do.  If you decide to run every day but hate running, its not going to be a sustainable activity.  Gotta remember these are life changes you are making.  Don't make a plan to do something to lose weight that you don't plan on living with the rest of your life.   Most people, when doing an activity that is not something they enjoy will quit earlier than something they do enjoy.  Enjoyment increases drive!  I have seen jumping rope, weight lifting, running, biking, yoga.. the list is endless.  Keep trying them until you find one that trips your fitness trigger.  Many fitness classes have a free class or at least a lower rate for a trial.  Go an search and find your bliss!

 

Sounds to me like diet might be on track.  Make sure you are measuring your food!  Americans in general (I totally fell into this class) believe portion sizes to be far bigger than what they actually are.  Invest in a scale.  Doesn't have to be super expensive, but at least to begin with make sure you are weighing and logging your food. Every time! You may be eating more than what you think.  It really took me 2+ years before I could correctly eyeball a single serving.

 

On the flip side, it may not be enough calories.  Look online for a BMR calculator.  There are many of them out there that will give you the same number.  Find out what your base rate of calories should be.  You should always eat that many (1200-1300 is usually absolute minimum).  You should add calories based on your activity level.  I am not going to harp really on what you eat.  I like a steak, or hamburgers, spaghetti...  Lots of things some say, you shouldn't eat.  I think it's just important to really learn portion size and control.  Everything in moderation.  Just make sure you are expending more calories than you put in.  

 

Again, don't make changes that you can't stick with.  As in High Protein/ Low/no Carb or Vegetarian/Vegan diets.  These have shown to take the weight off, but is it something you're going to want to stick with forever?  If the answer is "no", the result will always be that the weight comes back.

 

Last thing, give it time.  As you said:


  I am mid 60s, sedentary for years.


It took you years to get the way you are now, and it's going to take some time to get to your goal.  Just keep on trucking and you'll get there!  We'll be here to cheer your success when you do!

 

Hope this helps

Jamie

View best answer in original post

Best Answer
5 REPLIES 5

In a word, yes. 

 

In many words: (You should consult your physician first. I don't wear a labcoat and am not a doctor.) 

 

First, in order to make progress, we've got to identify the metrics used to assess your progress. Just using the scale is not going to be sufficient for most people. 

 

How they feel

How the clothes fit 

Tape Measure

Comments from friends/family

 

 

The two things that will always lead to disappointment are 

  1. Unrealistic expectations
  2. Unrealized expectations

 

With the first - it's your own fault if you set crazy goals. With the second, it's probably a flaw in your plan, or the execution of that plan. 

 

So - you need a plan. 

 

That starts with coming to a source of information that can explain what you need to know. Instead, you came here. That could be good or bad, depending on who chimes in. 

 

So - first, since I have no idea what you know and what you don't, I may insult your intelligence. This is not intentional. Maybe someone else lurking doesn't know and you do. <shrug> 

 

Forget calories. Think of calories as a metric used to measure nutrients. We don't run off of calories. They really don't even exist. Our bodies work from nutrients absorbed through food and drink that we consume. But - if we don't measure the calories, the best plans can fall awry. 

 

3500 calories is a pound. 3500 calories is also about 16 ounces. 

 

When you eat - you've put food into a tube. Your mouth to the ..end is one giant tube. When you eat, some of that food is absorbed to run your body. Some is stored to run your body later. Some stays in the tube. What you eat determines what runs your body. How much you eat determines what is stored to run your body later. The fiber content in your food (and other insoluble foods) determine what stays in the tube. 

 

So - what you ate this morning is still in the tube, or is being used to run your body now. If you get on the scale daily - which a lot of us do - you're really just measuring your weight, plus the weight of what's in the tube. This will change throughout your day. It's best to look at trends, what you way over time. If the trend is downward, you're doing well. If not, you need to evaluate your diet - what you eat and how much you eat. 

 

To lose more than 1 pound a week - you've got to reduce your intake and/or increase your calories burned beyond 500 calories a day. (500*7=3500, or 1 pound)

 

On average - if you walk for an hour a day - depending on your mobility and the terrain, you'll burn at least 300 calories. I'm a big guy, I'd burn about 700, maybe 800 calories. 

 

We're all different, so what you burn is not going to be found online. Even the Fitbit, for all it's technological marvel, is only a guess. An educated guess, but still a guess. But, it gives you a great starting point. 

 

Measure the calories of what you eat every time. If you can't be sure of the calories - look it up on the internet and guess a higher value, erring on the side of caution. Try to lift weights followed by quick, intense movements for best results. If you're not confident in your ability to do this, you should probably just take things slow and work into it. 

 

I recommend you read this just to have some information backed by research. 

 

https://bengreenfieldfitness.com/2013/12/diet-myth-news-flash-eating-less-cause-fat-loss/

 

To lose more than 1pound a week, you'll have to burn 1000 calories more per day than what you eat in day. If your body burns 1200 calories at rest, and your activity level through the day cooks off another 1000 calories, than a 1200 calorie a day should do the trick. But, even then, it's a very slow process. You didn't get fat overnight, you're not going to get in shape overnight either. 

 

Remember, you're after optimum health - not optimum weight. Get a check up, have your blood pressure evaluated, blood tests done, etc. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Those who have no idea what they are doing genuinely have no idea that they don't know what they're doing. - John Cleese
Best Answer
0 Votes

Here's the problem, losing weight is not linear.  Some people can eat 500 less than they burn, and lost 1.5 lbs a week.  Others have to eat 750 or 1000 calories.  It just depends on your metabolism.

 

First all, don't eat any less.  1200-1300 is the minimum a woman should eat.  So you can't and should not go any lower.

 

So I'm going to guess that you are burning around 1800 calories? 

 

First all, you have two major strikes against your.  Your age, and that you are postmenopausal.  Both are going to make it harder for you to lose weight.  I can tell you what I did at 49, but I'm male, and my hormones have not declined significantly yet. 

 

My wife on the other hand is 54, and she been going through menopause for a while.  Hot flashes from hell right now.  She's managed to lose 40 lbs, but she's very busy taking care of our animals.  She gets 15000-20000 steps a day.  But her issue was her diet, she was eating too little, and gaining weight.  She ate around 800 calories a day.  A simple diet change to 1500-1800, and she lost 40 lbs so far.

 

I was 281 lbs October last year.  Today I'm 206.  I did it by walking.  A LOT of walking.  At first 10-20 minutes, 1/4-1/2 a mile every other day.  By December I was up to 3 miles.  January I hit six miles.  February I started walking every day.  April I added occasional bike rides.  June I added Weight training.  My wife has just added weight training.

 

When I was walking slower, but 4-6 miles, I walked about 1:15 to 2:00 hours a day.  Today because I walk much faster, I usually walk between 1:00-1:15 now.  I life weights 1 hour, 3 times a week.  Although today I'm adding a second weight routine for my legs.  But this routine will be 20 minutes is my guess, every other day.

 

The old adage is that you need to either eat less, or burn more.  Since you can't eat less, you will have to burn more.  Which at your age, isn't easy, especially if you have any mobility issues.

 

Can you lose 1 lbs a week, maybe, 1/2 is more likely at your age.  But the good news the more active you get, the more in shape you get, the more you will lose. 

 

So give it time.  A lot of time.  It took me 10 months to lose 75 lbs.  I don't see any reason you can't lose 10-20 lbs within the next year.  But it will take time.

 

Be patient, keep active, and you will get there! 

 

You have been cleared by your doctor to exercise?  As long as you capable of it, then go for it.

John | Texas,USA | Surge | Aria | Blaze | Windows | iPhone | Always consult with a doctor regarding all medical issues. Keep active!!!
Best Answer

Really is tough for a woman, who has been sedentary and is mid 60s.

Tough but you can get there.  

Best Answer

Hey @Bobbinyc

 

First things first, consult a doctor.  They may or may not recommend something other than this.  I am not a doctor, I just keep at what shows results and what I enjoy.  Because I think bottom line, if you don't at least somewhat enjoy it.. you won't keep at it.

 

Here's the thing... I have never seen a fool proof workout/diet plan for everyone.  There is no magic formula as in (eat this) + (do this) = (drop weight like magic).  Every one has their own thing.  There are a million diets, a million different ways to get active.  I don't necessarily think they are all 100% right.. or wrong for that matter.  If it works for you.. It works!

 

I personally think your activity level has everything to do with you.  Do what you can tolerate.  By that I mean general soreness is going to be something to get used to at least for a while.  As long as it is tolerable to you, keep it up.  Find an activity that you like to do.  If you decide to run every day but hate running, its not going to be a sustainable activity.  Gotta remember these are life changes you are making.  Don't make a plan to do something to lose weight that you don't plan on living with the rest of your life.   Most people, when doing an activity that is not something they enjoy will quit earlier than something they do enjoy.  Enjoyment increases drive!  I have seen jumping rope, weight lifting, running, biking, yoga.. the list is endless.  Keep trying them until you find one that trips your fitness trigger.  Many fitness classes have a free class or at least a lower rate for a trial.  Go an search and find your bliss!

 

Sounds to me like diet might be on track.  Make sure you are measuring your food!  Americans in general (I totally fell into this class) believe portion sizes to be far bigger than what they actually are.  Invest in a scale.  Doesn't have to be super expensive, but at least to begin with make sure you are weighing and logging your food. Every time! You may be eating more than what you think.  It really took me 2+ years before I could correctly eyeball a single serving.

 

On the flip side, it may not be enough calories.  Look online for a BMR calculator.  There are many of them out there that will give you the same number.  Find out what your base rate of calories should be.  You should always eat that many (1200-1300 is usually absolute minimum).  You should add calories based on your activity level.  I am not going to harp really on what you eat.  I like a steak, or hamburgers, spaghetti...  Lots of things some say, you shouldn't eat.  I think it's just important to really learn portion size and control.  Everything in moderation.  Just make sure you are expending more calories than you put in.  

 

Again, don't make changes that you can't stick with.  As in High Protein/ Low/no Carb or Vegetarian/Vegan diets.  These have shown to take the weight off, but is it something you're going to want to stick with forever?  If the answer is "no", the result will always be that the weight comes back.

 

Last thing, give it time.  As you said:


  I am mid 60s, sedentary for years.


It took you years to get the way you are now, and it's going to take some time to get to your goal.  Just keep on trucking and you'll get there!  We'll be here to cheer your success when you do!

 

Hope this helps

Jamie

Best Answer

Thanks for all the advice and perspective.  I think I just have to keep gradually adding more and more activity and, as I continue to recuperate and get stronger, just push more.  It feels like I'm doing a lot because I'm coming from sedentary, but I think I have a ways to go.

Thanks

The activity that seems impossible today, will soon be your warm-up
Best Answer
0 Votes