Cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Calories in vs calories out

ANSWERED
Hi I'm a little confused on how the whole calorie system works, I know how weight loss works and all (I've lost 115 pounds in the past) but I'm currently bodybuilding and now it's time for me to shred fat again however I'm new to the whole Fitbit system because I know how calorie deficits and surpluses work but I need help knowing how that's all setup on the Fitbit. So if throught the day I've burned 2300 calories does that mean if I eat 2300 calories will I maintain weight or am I creating a 500 deficit I'm not to sure, currently I'm aiming for a 750 calorie deficit so does that mean if I burn 2300 calories throught the day do I eat 2050 calories or do I eat 1550 calories can some one please explain to me
Best Answer
0 Votes
1 BEST ANSWER

Accepted Solutions

First of regardless of what your fitbit tells you, you should never eat less than 1800 calories.  So if you can make your goal that day, you need to exercise more.

 

Your fitibit throught out the day will give you an estimate of how many calories burned.  This is based on your BMR, plus your activity. 

 

On fitbit.com, log, food plan is a gear with a drop down setting.  Personalized, vs sedentiary.  By default it is set to sendendiary.  So early in the morning it will show a very small amout of remaining calories.  And you have to be active to earn more calories for you to eat.  Personalize will tell you how many calories you have left to eat based on what you have done previously.  So if every day you burn 2700 calories, and eat 1800, at midnight it will tell you to eat 1800 caloires. 

 

Ideally, if you were to eat the same number of calories out, you would not gain weight.  However what you log for food, and how many calories you burn are estimates.  Both can be wrong by 250 calories or more.  So everyone has to tweak their diet to find there normal max for the day.

 

So if you only burn 2300 calories, and you have set your fitbit to a 750 deficit, your fitbit will tell you to eat 1550 calories.  Which is TOO LOW.  You would need to eat at least 1800 calories, so you need to increase your activities by 250 calories.  Go for a 2-3 mile walk would do it. If you don't increase you calories burned, then you will have to go over that day.

 

1800 is minimum calories most men need to eat in a day.  If you really want to eat less, work with a nutrionist to determine your healthy minimum.  Eating under your minimum will tend to burn muscle, and gain fat.  Exactly opposite of what you want to do.

 

Now you know to add muscle with bodybuilding you need to eat more protein.  The problem is in a calorie deficient diet it's ALMOST impossible to gain muscle and lose fat at the same time.  You are just not eating enough protein to add muscle mass. 

So my suggestion is limit the time on the weights and concentrate on cardio activities to burn fat.  You can do some weights to maintain muscle mass.  But you need to do an hour or two of cardio a day if you want to lose a lot of weight.  

A 750 deficit is for someone that wants to lose 20-40 lbs.  500 deficit for 10-20 lbs, and 250 deficit for 10 or less.  1000 deficit for those need to lose more than 40.

 

Having a high deficit, and very few pounds to lose causes the body to burn muscle, and gain fat.  Again the opposite of what you are trying to do.

 

Good luck!

John | Texas,USA | Surge | Aria | Blaze | Windows | iPhone | Always consult with a doctor regarding all medical issues. Keep active!!!

View best answer in original post

Best Answer
5 REPLIES 5

If you went by "Fitbit" calories in vs calories out you would be gaining lots of weight. Fitbit adds BMR to its calculations among other things. I use MyFitnessPal to trackmy diet, I only use fitbit to track my steps and miles walked,

Best Answer
0 Votes

First of regardless of what your fitbit tells you, you should never eat less than 1800 calories.  So if you can make your goal that day, you need to exercise more.

 

Your fitibit throught out the day will give you an estimate of how many calories burned.  This is based on your BMR, plus your activity. 

 

On fitbit.com, log, food plan is a gear with a drop down setting.  Personalized, vs sedentiary.  By default it is set to sendendiary.  So early in the morning it will show a very small amout of remaining calories.  And you have to be active to earn more calories for you to eat.  Personalize will tell you how many calories you have left to eat based on what you have done previously.  So if every day you burn 2700 calories, and eat 1800, at midnight it will tell you to eat 1800 caloires. 

 

Ideally, if you were to eat the same number of calories out, you would not gain weight.  However what you log for food, and how many calories you burn are estimates.  Both can be wrong by 250 calories or more.  So everyone has to tweak their diet to find there normal max for the day.

 

So if you only burn 2300 calories, and you have set your fitbit to a 750 deficit, your fitbit will tell you to eat 1550 calories.  Which is TOO LOW.  You would need to eat at least 1800 calories, so you need to increase your activities by 250 calories.  Go for a 2-3 mile walk would do it. If you don't increase you calories burned, then you will have to go over that day.

 

1800 is minimum calories most men need to eat in a day.  If you really want to eat less, work with a nutrionist to determine your healthy minimum.  Eating under your minimum will tend to burn muscle, and gain fat.  Exactly opposite of what you want to do.

 

Now you know to add muscle with bodybuilding you need to eat more protein.  The problem is in a calorie deficient diet it's ALMOST impossible to gain muscle and lose fat at the same time.  You are just not eating enough protein to add muscle mass. 

So my suggestion is limit the time on the weights and concentrate on cardio activities to burn fat.  You can do some weights to maintain muscle mass.  But you need to do an hour or two of cardio a day if you want to lose a lot of weight.  

A 750 deficit is for someone that wants to lose 20-40 lbs.  500 deficit for 10-20 lbs, and 250 deficit for 10 or less.  1000 deficit for those need to lose more than 40.

 

Having a high deficit, and very few pounds to lose causes the body to burn muscle, and gain fat.  Again the opposite of what you are trying to do.

 

Good luck!

John | Texas,USA | Surge | Aria | Blaze | Windows | iPhone | Always consult with a doctor regarding all medical issues. Keep active!!!
Best Answer

I only use my fitbit to track miles walked per hour. I use MyFitnessPal to track my food and excersize. When I set it up( MFP) I was 225 lbs ,lightly to medium active, set my goal weight to 190 lbs with the intention of losing 1 to 1 1/2 lbs per week. So to reach that goal ( which I have) they set my calories to 1700 per day. For the exercize part you would record what exercize you did(for me it was walking 3 1/2 miles in an hour every day) giving me an extra 350 calories to consume. Nine months later I now weigh 185lbs (40 lbs in nine months is 1 1/4 lbs a week) I am 63 years old and feel great! MFP also tracks sodium , sugar, cholesterol along with your fat, carbs and protein and keeping all this in range also helps your overall health, so if I ever decide to bulk up maybe I will start lifting weights  and eating more calories. So staying at my base 1700 cal is working fine for me,   

Best Answer
Myfitnesspal for food/calories in, Fitbit for exercise/calories out.
Best Answer
0 Votes
Why do my remaining calories keep outing down through out the day even though I haven't inserted any new figures or information? my spent calories are raising, so shouldn't my remaining balance at least remain the same? the same?
Best Answer
0 Votes