12-28-2013 19:42
12-28-2013 19:42
whats the differance
Answered! Go to the Best Answer.
12-28-2013 20:30
12-28-2013 20:30
In an absolute sense, there is no difference. In a healthy eating sense, the more processed the food the less healthy the end result. So a 'good' carb is as little processed as possible, has as few chemicals as possible, uses healthier versions of ingredients ( whole wheat flour vs enriched bleached white flour), and is as natural in all senses as possible (natural food coloring vs chemicals for example). Many people also believe that 'bad' carbs are high in fat or sugar, such as doughnuts, soda, fast food items, etc. In this case I believe the point is that the food is not nutrient dense and will not provide healthy ingredients but will fill you up with unnecessary things (chemicals, hydrogenated oils, sodium) with a lot of calories. So, a basic boiled or baked potato is a healthy carb, but french fries are not healthy. And there are variations to all of these as well. Some people believe that carbs that are starchy are less healthy than carbs that are not. Some people believe that ALL carbs are unhealthy. Most research does not support these ideas though.
12-28-2013 20:30
12-28-2013 20:30
In an absolute sense, there is no difference. In a healthy eating sense, the more processed the food the less healthy the end result. So a 'good' carb is as little processed as possible, has as few chemicals as possible, uses healthier versions of ingredients ( whole wheat flour vs enriched bleached white flour), and is as natural in all senses as possible (natural food coloring vs chemicals for example). Many people also believe that 'bad' carbs are high in fat or sugar, such as doughnuts, soda, fast food items, etc. In this case I believe the point is that the food is not nutrient dense and will not provide healthy ingredients but will fill you up with unnecessary things (chemicals, hydrogenated oils, sodium) with a lot of calories. So, a basic boiled or baked potato is a healthy carb, but french fries are not healthy. And there are variations to all of these as well. Some people believe that carbs that are starchy are less healthy than carbs that are not. Some people believe that ALL carbs are unhealthy. Most research does not support these ideas though.
12-29-2013 02:38
12-29-2013 02:38
Vegetables are good carbs - often high in fiber, easy for the body to digest, and are full of vitamins and minerals that are good for us.
Higher calorie carbs like bread/pasta/garbage food are usually looked at as bad carbs because they
are high in fat content, longer to digest, and easy to overeat on them.
12-29-2013 04:13
12-29-2013 04:13
this helps
12-29-2013 19:22
12-29-2013 19:22
Will Rogers never met a Carbohydrate. "I never met a carbohydrate that I liked." This belief that a carbohydrate can be "heart healthy" can't be reconciled with the idea that carbohydrates make us fat.
12-30-2013 18:38
12-30-2013 18:38
Sugar powers our brains. Simple carbs: flour, pastries, candy, pasta, irish potatoes, and white rice release the sugar fast and then our brains demand more Complex carbs are slower acting, but they don't release the sugar all at once, it's a steady release over time, these are: corn, beans, and peas, fruit, whole grains. Vegetables have less sugar and release the sugar even more slowly. The fact is, our brains don't need much sugar. If our diets are rich in vegetables, we get plenty of sugar to power our brains and tons of nutrients to power our bodies.
So, good carbs release slowly over time and bad carbs hit us fast and hard and are used up very quickly and that makes our brains tell we need more and more and more and more and ........
12-31-2013 05:00
12-31-2013 05:00
steff...that is a GREAT explanation. I cut out suger 4 months ago and was amazed at how much better I felt and how much more focused I became. I had been on an antibiotic for cystic acne (I'm 37) for almost a year. After eliminating sugar, my face has been comletely clear. I ration starchy veggies, too, since I'm still trying to drop about 20 more lbs, but I am a walking example of your explanation by 100%!! When I cut out sugar, I quit thinking about food all the time, too!
01-25-2014 01:43
01-25-2014 01:43
Except for the obvious fact that our brains can be powered in the absence of sugar or glucose.
01-25-2014 04:51 - edited 01-25-2014 05:15
01-25-2014 04:51 - edited 01-25-2014 05:15
"Higher calorie carbs like bread/pasta/garbage food are usually looked at as bad carbs because they
are high in fat content, longer to digest, and easy to overeat on them."
Bread and pasta are mainly composed of carbs and do not contain a lot of fat. Fat doesn't make you fat nor is it "bad", your body needs fat to help absorb certain nutrients. Many people eat healthy and lose/maintain weight successfully on high fat, low carb diets. You *want* carbs that take longer to digest, not the other way around. Carbs that digest quickly like pasta/bread (simple carbs like foods high in sugar and low in fiber) cause insulin spikes which leave you feeling hungry again shortly after and cause cravings and energy depletion.
There's quite the difference in how a bowl of Lucky Charms is going to make you feel when compared to a bowl of whole grain oats in the morning. The first would leave me jittery, hyper and burn away quickly causing a insulin crash where I'd be more tired, irritable and hungry again which would lead to me craving another bowl to boost my insulin levels again. The second is less likely to cause a huge insulin spike and the energy it provides me with will not cause a surge of energy that depletes quickly. Instead, it will release energy slower and I will stay satisfied longer and not experience the "crash" that the bowl of Lucky Charms gave me because whole grain oats have a higher fiber vs. sugar content.
Higher calories does not equal "bad" carbs either. Sweet potatoes and bananas tend to be higher calories, whole grains and legumes have a high calorie content but they also contain a lot of nutrients, vitamins, antioxidents, fiber and protein. The same applies to fat. Fat has nearly 2x the amount of calories per gram as carbs and protein yet monounsaturated fats and omega 3s are essential and healthy. Oils like those found in nuts, seeds, olives, avocado, fish, chicken, eggs, plants, etc.
When comparing food I prefer *not* to put labels like "good" or "bad". It isn't so black and white and I don't apply guilt to the food I eat. I just try to choose more nutrient dense foods to make up most of my diet. As far as carbs are concerned I try to get plenty of veg, legumes, fruit, dairy, whole grains over food that contains less nutrients per calorie count and added sugars/sodium/preservatives like your pastas and breads. Does that mean pasta and bread never have a place in my diet? No, they just make up a small part of it. I have a serving of whole grain bread once a day and not a big pasta person so I eat it maybe a few times every couple months and use less than a serving size.
To keep it simple, when choosing carbs you want higher fiber and low on added sugar. Carbs by name you'd want to limit or omit from your diet include; white flour and high sugar breakfast cereals (other heavily refined grains), pastries, cakes, cookies, donuts, soda, candy, etc.
Carbs you want to include more of in your diet; whole grains, legumes, lentils, vegetables, fruit, low fat dairy. Of course individual exceptions may apply.