Cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Grumble grumble BodyFat gripe gripe stupid Aria

ANSWERED

I'm in a bad mood right now.

 

After 3 months of pretty intense barbell training----  my weight and body fat level are both back up to where they were in October:  148 pounds and 34% BF.   I'm not surprised that my weight has gone up, because I'm eating more.  By why is my bodyfat level back up into "obese"?   (This isn't one anomalous reading on the scale.  It's a trend.)

 

I remember how I looked and felt in October.  I had lost a bunch of weight, but I still had pretty significant rolls of fat across my back and sides.   Now, it's different.  My back is fairly muscular, and there's a bit of padding, but no big rolls that I can grab.   I still have a bit more belly than I'd really like, but I'm significantly more hourglassy than I was before.  

 

If not for the Aria readings, I'd be absolutely convinced that I had put on mostly lean body mass, and only an insignificant amount of fat.  I look pretty good, and I feel great. I'm getting stronger with each training session.   But that **ahem** Aria tells me I'm obese.  Where is all this fat I supposedly have?   How does 148 pounds and 34% BF look and feel so different than it did back in October?

 

I know no one can really answer this.  I also know that scales like the Aria aren't accurate.  But the whole "you're still obese despite all of your hard work" thing has got me down.  Argh.  I've definitely put on a bunch of muscle I didn't have before---I can SEE it, and I've got the log books showing how much heavier my lifts are than before, but according to the stupid Aria, it's fat.  😞

 

Grumble grumble.  

 

 

Best Answer
1 BEST ANSWER

Accepted Solutions

I don't have much faith in the body fat percentage on the Aria scale. It changes too quickly to be realistic.

 

If you keep a journal of your weight lifting, you know if your muscles are getting bigger and stronger.

View best answer in original post

Best Answer
3 REPLIES 3

I don't have much faith in the body fat percentage on the Aria scale. It changes too quickly to be realistic.

 

If you keep a journal of your weight lifting, you know if your muscles are getting bigger and stronger.

Best Answer

Yeah, you're right.  

 

I think the thing that really bugs me is that I rely on the Fitbit to give me an idea how many calories I burn in a day.  An accurate bodyfat number would help with that.  

 

 

Oh well.  

Best Answer
0 Votes

I don't understand why this is the "accepted solution." It sounds more like "Please don't expect your $100+ scale to actually WORK." 

Best Answer