Cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

In the Zone? "Under target"

ANSWERED

Before buying my Fitbit ChargeHR  I have managed to lose 3.5 stone since May.

 

This is without any apps, weighing food, anything.

 

Since buying my Charge my weight isn't dropping at all.

 

I think it is because I am understanding the "under target" reading correctly.

 

Everyday I am in yellow. I am meant to eat 1800 calories a day to lose weight (this is what I have been doing since May) - but to be honest I do not get close to it now and am not hungry anymore.

 

If I try to increase my intake and get "into the zone (in green)" will my weight loss start again?

 

I know if you under eat you body holds on to the fat so to speak? It seems strange having to eat more when I am not hungry in order to lose weight?

 

Would love to hear advice 🙂

Best Answer
0 Votes
1 BEST ANSWER

Accepted Solutions

The more weight you lose, the slower it will start to come off.

 

As an example:

If you were eating 6000 calories a day and reduced it to 1800, the pounds will come off very quickly at first. 6000 less 1800 equals 4200 calories a day x 7 days a week = 29,900 less per week divided 3500 per pound - 8.4 pounds lost in one week.

 

But as you're nearing your goal weight, there's not much you can shave off of 1800 calories that is going to make you lose it as quickly as you did at first.  So you get used to being happy with a 1lb. or less per week until you reach your goal weight.   Hope this helps.

View best answer in original post

Best Answer
6 REPLIES 6

Hi @SunsetRunner

 

Moved your post from the Charge HR to to the weight loss section since more relevant to the topic.

 

If not being hungry, having no appetite yet, or feeling needing to force feed your wonderful body when eating, wait until being hungry again and eat when your body needs more nourishment.

 

It's possible to not feeling hungry though when seeing food, possible that your body is saying 'that looks appealing..' and when starting eating, your body asking for more until being satisfied..

 

Try eating until comfortably satisfied, not stuffed.

Best Answer
0 Votes
I just don't understand why I am being told that I have more Cala left and under target and have now only lost a pound in two weeks?
Best Answer

I have both the Zip and the Surge. The Surge shows I burn about 800 calories more a day than the Zip does. This is because the calories burned is related to heart rate and not only to steps. Based on months of calorie counting, I think the Zip underestimates the calories burned and the Surge overestimates them.

 

The solution is simple. Maintain a larger calorie deficit. I don't recommend going below the base requirement. This means getting more exercise.

 

If you aren't losing weight, you will need to make the training plan more aggressive. 

 

 

Best Answer

@SunsetRunner wrote:
I just don't understand why I am being told that I have more Cala left and under target and have now only lost a pound in two weeks?

The fitbit app works on averages and not specifics.  All it knows is your age, height and weight and uses those along with your activity level to estimate what you need to accomplish your goals, but it is NOT an absolute.  There are other factors that have substantial impact on your calorie burn including your muscle density and the intensity of your activity.

 

Intensity is a huge deal is exercise.  I can stroll, I can walk, I can jog, I can run and I can sprint.  Each step in this equation is a step up in intensity.  Factor in the amount of muscle tissue that is involved in this expenditure and you can approximate the burn.  If you don't know either of these, the burn rate given by your device is only an approximation based on averages.

 

Even fat takes some metabolic energy to sustain.  You lost some weight using the 1800 calories a day mark, but now are not, so what has happened is that your metabolism (BMR and daily burn rate) has slowed so that your daily activity vs expenditure has come into equallibrium.  You need to up the intensity of your activity.  Whatever you have been doing, do it harder.  Walk faster, walk up hill, jog.  Start weight lifting if you do not already.  The calories you do eat should be high in protein because you are calorie restricting.  This will provide your muscles enough amino acids to prevent atrophy.  If you add strength training to your regiment you can even possibly increase your total muscle mass and increase your metabolism and resume your burn. 

 

Bottom line, don't rely on the numbers.  I would also encourage you to drop to 1500 calories a day with increased exercise.  You diet needs to be healthy....good, high quality protien and good high quality fats with some veggies for vitamines.  Examples of high quality protein include: eggs, lean grassfed beef, cold water fish and lamb.  Fats include fish oils, olive oil and fats from grassfed beef and lamb. 

 

A bit about exercise intensity.  There is steady state and High Intensity Interval Training (HIIT).  Steady state tends to burn fat during the exercise.  HIIT will throw you into anerobic state that will burn fat both during and after exercise.  Steady state tends to get people into a level and keeps them there without further challenge.  It has it's place, but can stall weight loss.  Your body adpats to become more efficent with what you do and unless you keep challenging it, you'll reach a state of equallibrium.  HIIT examples would include running all out for 30 seconds, then jog or walk for 90 seconds and repeat at least 7 more times.  As you get in better shape, increase to 45 seconds and so on.  You always have to push.  In the beginning of exercise this comes fairly easy.  For example, I started walking everyday and getting in my steps.  Then I started adding intervals of jogging to my walks.  Slowly I am building up to where I can run.  Distance and speed gradually increase, but once I get in good shape I'll have to find ways to keep challenging my body.  Running faster, up more hills, adding a backpack with weight.  Somehow you always have to improve.  I also do weight training 3 times a week.  Only 30 min and all compound exercises but I try to get heavier.

 

So listen to your body and make it work if you want to continue the weight loss.  You don't have to kill yourself, but you do have to push yourself a little.  Good luck

“Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won't come in.”
― Isaac Asimov

“Being ignorant is not so much a shame, as being unwilling to learn.”
― Benjamin Franklin
Best Answer

Be sure you are taking measurements also.  You may be adding muscle which weighs more.  Scales mean very little by themselves, get those measurements weekly.  You may be pleasantly surprised.

Best Answer

The more weight you lose, the slower it will start to come off.

 

As an example:

If you were eating 6000 calories a day and reduced it to 1800, the pounds will come off very quickly at first. 6000 less 1800 equals 4200 calories a day x 7 days a week = 29,900 less per week divided 3500 per pound - 8.4 pounds lost in one week.

 

But as you're nearing your goal weight, there's not much you can shave off of 1800 calories that is going to make you lose it as quickly as you did at first.  So you get used to being happy with a 1lb. or less per week until you reach your goal weight.   Hope this helps.

Best Answer