Cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Fitbit Sense overestimating calories?

Replies are disabled for this topic. Start a new one or visit our Help Center.

From the first day I had the feeling it was over-estimating calories burned. By relaxed walking it was showing 450 calories/hour.

Against the treadmill and Spin Cycling, FitBit shows 150 calories more.

3rd day of having it and almost every day I burn around 3700-3800 calories when I exercise and around 3,200 calories when not.

No other fitness tracker gave me so high a number before. Unless it's really accurate this time around.

Anyone else had this thought ?

 

 

Moderator edit: subject for clarity 

Best Answer
15 REPLIES 15

Hi @SunsetRunner, it's nice to see you again in our Community Forum. 

 

I appreciate your participation in the Forums and sharing your concern about your Fitbit Sense overestimating calories burned. Thank you for the details shared, I am glad to assist you. Fitbit devices estimate calories burned based on the your personal information, your basal metabolic rate (BMR), and the activity tracked by your device. The calorie burn estimate also takes heart rate into account. I recommend confirming that your weight and height are correct in the Fitbit app. For more information, see How do I manage my Fitbit profile?

 

You can find information about how your calories burned are calculated and check the tips to make sure your daily activity is accurate at How does my Fitbit device calculate my daily activity?

Keep me posted on the outcome. I'll be around if you have any additional questions.

Want to discuss ways to increase your activity? Visit Get Moving in the Lifestyle Discussion Forum.

Best Answer

Agree with @SunsetRunner regarding calorie counting. The amount of calories Fitbit tells me I burned is outrageous. If I ate that many calories in a day I'd gain 10 lbs of fat in a month. Only reason to eat that many calories is to bulk up, but when bulking, you're OVER-eating. The calories burned is supposed to just show what to eat to maintain weight. To maintain weight I just subtract out the number of calories added from steps and only add calories burned from specific exercises which I get by manually entering the exercise into MyFitnessPal.    

Best Answer

@mbarylski 

I thought the same. It can't be that I burned around 4,000 calories. I don't eat nearly as much and I didn't lose weight.

That made me think, that something is out of place here. But fitbit is taking advice from scientists and I should trust that.

My BMR is 1,918 calories. Hard to believe I burn another 2,000 calories on top of that. What else can I say.

Best Answer

@SunsetRunner LOL, yea, I know. Frankly I think the models are off. I'm pretty sure all the trackers will say about the same thing. I don't know why the models are so far off though especially with scientists backing it. I've always had a fairly high metabolism, although slowing down as I get older, but I still can't eat that many calories. 😂

Best Answer

@mbarylski either it's not well thought out or we, the common mortals, don't know the science behind this calorie burning thing.

Best Answer

       I'm having this problem too but its waaaayy over yours. My calorie count is averaging 5500 calories per day when I only run for 30 minutes on the treadmill per day. My bmr is around 3400 calories because of my activity level, workouts are around 650 calories added to my bmr, and that makes 4050 calories per day. I'm 6 foot 1, 260 pounds and im 23. I put all of these on my fitbit account profile and that's leaving around 1400 calories unaccounted for which is pretty messed up considering this is a 350 dollar fitness tracker lol.

Best Answer

       I'm not saying fitbit is a bad fitness tracker because I could be burning those 1400 extra calories by just normal walking, like walking to the kitchen, bathroom, etc. 24/7 heart rate monitoring could be a factor in this as well. Maybe technology is just smarter than me lol. Still would be nice to get some help on this issue to see if it is a fitbit issue.

Best Answer

I'm wearing my old fitbit and the Sense for about 4 days now. The Sense of running about 500 to 700 calories more per day and more steps also. I record my calorie intake each day and per the sense I should be losing weight but it is not the case. I think fitbit inflates the burn to make you feel good. I hope they correct it.

Best Answer

I hope it's not that inaccurate. I only get a little over 2000 most days on mine. I do wonder about the steps though. I'll wake up with up to a hundred and fifty steps recorded. I must be moving around a lot.

Best Answer

I agree with u i am facing same issue. I have hardly moved 2000 steps it shows 942 calories burnt.....thats not possible with my current weight and height.

Best Answer

I just switched from the Blaze to the Sense and my calorie count is 300-400 higher per day on the sense. I believe the sense may be overestimating calories burned from walking around in my office building bc my workout calories are about the same. 

Best Answer

Agreed as to over estimating calories burnt, typically 5 to 7 calories per minute, during relaxed casual walking vs under estimating calories, typically 1.6 calories per minute, when doing intense spinning. I spin in the 150 to 175 watt range measured with calibrated electronic equipment.  I am an electronics engineer so I know how to measure this stuff.  

 

 

Calculation shown below is from "gearandgrit<dot>com".  The muscle efficiency of a human can vary quite a bit depending upon activity, age, health conditions etc. so calorie counts may not accurately reflect true burn rate.  What can be accurately measured is your output power.  Think of your spin bike as an engine dynamometer setup to measure leg power instead of engine power.  I track on an Excel spreadsheet the power that is generated by my spin bike. 

From Watts to Calories

If you know duration  (time spent cycling) and you have average power during that time, you  can quite easily calculate energy.

Power(Watts) = energy(Joules) / time(seconds)

We can figure out our energy using the equation above, but unfortunately, it’s in joules. We need to get to calories so we use the following conversion:

1 Joule =  0.238902957619 calories

Note, that what we commonly call a calorie, is actually a kcal or Calorie. So we need to divide by a factor of 1000 to find our common usage kcal (when you look at a nutrition label those calories are in fact kcals).

There are two types of calories: A small calorie(symbol: cal) – 1 cal is the amount of energy required to raise one gram of water by one degree Celsius. A large Calorie (symbol: Cal, kcal) – 1 Cal is the amount of energy required to raise one kilogram of water by one degree Celsius.

We also need to account for human inefficiency. Like any machine the human body is far from perfectly efficient – it has to burn more than 1 joule of real energy to output 1 joule of measured energy through a power meter. The efficiency of cycling humans is between 20-25% (so your body’s many systems and inefficiencies burn 4-5J of energy for every 1J you deliver to the pedals).

This means we should divide any measured joules figure by 0.2 to 0.25 to find out our actual expenditure.

By coincidence, a joule is  0.000239006 calories, or if we multiply by 1000 to get kilocalories approximately 0.24. How convenient!

So, assuming a human with 24% efficiency, you can cancel those last two steps exactly, and assume that measured joules = real calories burned.

Take all the above into account and we can build a very simple equation for calculating calories burned while cycling from average wattage:

energy (kcal) = avg power (Watts) X duration (hours) X 3.6

You might be wondering where that 3.6 came from. It’s simply an adjust for time and the factor of 1000 reduction to get from cal to kcal (60 seconds/minute * 60 minutes/hour * 1/1000 cal/kcal = 3.6).

Best Answer
0 Votes

“my bmr is … because of my activity level” bmr is how much you burn at rest. active calories is on top of bmr. BMR is simply calculated based on your height weight and age.

Best Answer

I completely agree. Something is off. I walked for an hour this morning and my Sense says I burned over 1000 calories, while the treadmill says I burned 230. It makes no sense to me how the watch can be so far off. 

Best Answer
0 Votes

Fitbit Sense 2 here and yes, it does overestimate burned calories by an large margin. I'm 177cm/95kg male and Fitbit says that I burn 3100kcals in a day just by sitting in a chair doing nothing but typing code.

Real burn with other fitness trackers and by the rate I'm losing weight with my cal-intake is about 2200kcals with zero-activity day.

BUT I found a hack to get real results: I just but my weight to be 30kg and now Fitbit shows about right cal-burn 😄

But Fitbit-devs, please fix this. This is really harmful for anyone who is trying to lose weight and plan for food intake. If Fitbit figures where right, I would be losing over 1kg/week with my current diet (but in reality I'm losing 0.4kg/week)

Best Answer