Cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Food logging Fitbit vs MFP

Hi, I am trying to figure out if there is an advantage to logging my food to Fitbit vs my fitness pal and have it linked to my charge 4.  I have heard Fitbit is not as accurate as mfp as far as calories go. Does anyone prefer one over the other? If so why? Thanks 

Best Answer
0 Votes
4 REPLIES 4

I posted the following comment earlier this morning, but someone reported it as SPAM and it was removed. I guess because I even mentioned MFP.  I would prefer to use Fitbit all the time, but MFP does a much better job of accurately logging food items. 

 

Fitbit's food log is its Achilles' heel.

"I just started using MyFitnessPal (MFP) and synced it to Fitbit because I've become so frustrated with the limitations and inaccuracy of the Fitbit food log. More than 50% of all barcodes I enter are wrong. And when you attempt to enter the food manually, you're presented with a hodge-podge of options, most of which are also wrong compared to the food's nutrition label on the package. It's as if Fitbit accepts and maintains every item submitted without ever checking the accuracy of what's being submitted.

 

"That said, the other major problem I have with the Fitbit food log is the limitation of just 20 frequent and 20 recent food items, excluding custom entries. When trying to track calories in an effort to lose weight or just maintain weight, the ability to find and record food quickly is extremely important, so being able to quickly search through past food entries is crucial. Other apps do this very well, including MFP, which is why I started using it and synced it to Fitbit, but there's absolutely no reason why I should have to use two apps to get this functionality. Given the endless minutia of data that Fitbit maintains for years, I don't understand why Fitbit allows just 20 frequent items and 20 recent items."

Best Answer
0 Votes

I log my calories in MFP and sync it over. I find MFP matches the labels more correctly and has a wider option of food choices

Best Answer
0 Votes

Thank you for taking time to respond. I have heard people say the exact same thing you did. So I guess I will continue to just sync w mfp since I have 2 years of food in there already. I wasn’t losing, do I thought I’d throw that question out there. Thx much 

Best Answer
0 Votes

Thank you. I will just continue to sync it over too w mfp. 

Best Answer
0 Votes